فکر بنیانبانک مقالات روان‌شناسی
دسترسی آزاد پژوهشی داوری‌شده انگلیسی

Human vs machine judgment in safety-critical logistics: a philosophical inquiry into trust and control

قضاوت انسانی در برابر قضاوت ماشینی در لجستیک‌های حساس به ایمنی: پژوهشی فلسفی درباره اعتماد و کنترل

Martyna Bąchorek, Wiktoria Izdebska, Gustaw Krakowiak

Scientific Journal of Safety and Logistics 2026 Vol. 7(1)
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20402506

ورود برای خواندن متن کاملبرای خواندن متن کامل وارد حساب فکر بنیان شوید.

چکیده

This article examines the differences between human judgment and algorithmic decision-making in critical logistics systems, focusing on the implications for the concepts of trust and control. The aim of the study is to determine whether AI-based systems can perform functions equivalent to human judgment and what implications this has for operational safety and accountability in complex logistics systems. The study is based on an interdisciplinary analysis, including a review of the literature on artificial intelligence, system safety, and human factors research, as well as a philosophical analysis. This is supplemented by a case study of selected incidents related to the operation of automated systems in high-risk environments, which allows the identification of practical limitations in integrating humans and algorithmic systems. The results indicate that decisions generated by algorithmic systems are statistical and optimization-based, which distinguishes them from human judgment, which takes into account context, uncertainty, and emotions. Consequently, trust in AI systems takes the form of an indirect, user-dependent relationship rather than an autonomous property of the technology. At the same time, increasing levels of automation lead to a diffusion of responsibility and a reduction in direct control over decision-making processes. The findings indicate that full automation of decisions in critical safety systems. Consequently, trust in AI systems takes the form of an indirect, user-dependent relationship rather than an autonomous property of the technology.

چکیده به فارسی

این مقاله به بررسی تفاوت‌های میان قضاوت انسانی و تصمیم‌گیری الگوریتمی در سامانه‌های لجستیکی حساس به ایمنی می‌پردازد و پیامدهای آن را برای مفاهیم اعتماد و کنترل مورد تحلیل قرار می‌دهد. هدف این مطالعه تعیین این است که آیا سامانه‌های مبتنی بر هوش مصنوعی می‌توانند عملکردهایی معادل با قضاوت انسانی داشته باشند و این امر چه پیامدهایی برای ایمنی عملیاتی و پاسخگویی در سامانه‌های لجستیکی پیچیده دارد. این پژوهش مبتنی بر تحلیلی میان‌رشته‌ای است که شامل مرور ادبیات مرتبط با هوش مصنوعی، ایمنی سامانه و پژوهش‌های عوامل انسانی، همچنین تحلیل فلسفی می‌شود. این تحلیل با مطالعه موردی درباره برخی رخدادهای مرتبط با عملکرد سامانه‌های خودکار در محیط‌های پرخطر تکمیل شده است که امکان شناسایی محدودیت‌های عملی در یکپارچه‌سازی انسان و سامانه‌های الگوریتمی را فراهم می‌کند. نتایج نشان می‌دهد که تصمیمات تولیدشده توسط سامانه‌های الگوریتمی مبتنی بر آمار و بهینه‌سازی هستند که آن‌ها را از قضاوت انسانی که زمینه، عدم قطعیت و هیجانات را در نظر می‌گیرد، متمایز می‌کند. در نتیجه، اعتماد به سامانه‌های هوش مصنوعی به صورت یک رابطه غیرمستقیم و وابسته به کاربر شکل می‌گیرد و نه به عنوان یک ویژگی مستقل از فناوری. همزمان، افزایش سطوح خودکارسازی منجر به پخش مسئولیت و کاهش کنترل مستقیم بر فرایندهای تصمیم‌گیری می‌شود. یافته‌ها نشان می‌دهد که خودکارسازی کامل تصمیمات در سامانه‌های حساس به ایمنی... در نتیجه، اعتماد به سامانه‌های هوش مصنوعی به صورت یک رابطه غیرمستقیم و وابسته به کاربر شکل می‌گیرد و نه به عنوان یک ویژگی مستقل از فناوری.

ترجمه‌ی خودکار برای آشنایی سریع؛ برای نقل و ارجاع، متن اصلی ملاک است.

موضوع‌ها و کلیدواژه‌ها

هوشهیجانalgorithmic decision-makingcontroldiffusion of responsibilityhuman judgmenthuman-AI interactionlogisticssafety-critical systemstrust in AI

ارجاع

Bąchorek, M., Izdebska, W., & Krakowiak, G. (2026). Human vs machine judgment in safety-critical logistics: a philosophical inquiry into trust and control. Scientific Journal of Safety and Logistics, 7(1). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20402506

(Bąchorek et al., 2026)

دانلود BibTeX · دانلود RIS

گفت‌وگو

قوانین پرسش و گفتگو
  1. با احترام و بدون توهین، تحقیر، برچسب‌زنی یا حمله‌ی شخصی با دیگران گفتگو کنید.
  2. از نوشتن هرگونه اطلاعات هویتی یا قابل‌شناسایی مراجعان، بیماران یا اشخاص ثالث، از جمله نام، شماره‌ی تماس، تصویر، نشانی، محل کار یا جزئیات منحصربه‌فرد پرونده خودداری کنید.
  3. اگر درباره‌ی یک تجربه‌ی بالینی سؤال می‌کنید، اطلاعات را تا حد ممکن بی‌نام و کلی بیان کنید تا امکان شناسایی فرد وجود نداشته باشد.
  4. این بخش برای یادگیری و گفت‌وگوی علمی است و جایگزین ارزیابی، تشخیص، مشاوره یا روان‌درمانی شخصی نیست.
  5. در شرایط بحران یا خطر آسیب به خود یا دیگران، به این بخش اتکا نکنید و برای دریافت کمک فوری با اورژانس اجتماعی ۱۲۳ یا صدای مشاور بهزیستی ۱۴۸۰ تماس بگیرید.
  6. انتشار تبلیغات، معرفی خدمات شخصی، شماره‌ی تلفن، شناسه‌ی شبکه‌های اجتماعی، پیوند تبلیغاتی یا درخواست جذب مراجع در این بخش مجاز نیست.
  7. در بیان ادعاهای علمی، به‌ویژه درباره‌ی اثربخشی درمان‌ها، تشخیص یا یافته‌های پژوهشی، تا حد امکان نام منبع معتبر، مقاله یا راهنمای علمی را ذکر کنید.
  8. از ارائه‌ی تشخیص قطعی، تجویز درمان یا دارو و توصیه‌های بالینی شخصی به سایر کاربران خودداری کنید.
  9. پاسخ‌هایی که کارشناسان فکر بنیان می‌دهند با برچسب «پاسخ فکر بنیان» یا «کارشناس فکر بنیان» نمایش داده می‌شوند و سایر نوشته‌ها بیانگر نظر کاربران هستند.
  10. گزارش نوشته‌ی نامناسب: اگر نوشته‌ای حاوی نقض محرمانگی، محتوای آسیب‌زا، توهین، تبلیغ یا تخلف از این قوانین است، گزینه‌ی «گزارش» را انتخاب کنید تا تیم سایت بررسی کند.

برای پرسیدن و پاسخ دادن باید مشترک باشید. ورود

هنوز پرسشی منتشر نشده است.

مقاله‌های مرتبط

Awareness of Youth-Friendly Sexual and Reproductive Health Services among Undergraduate Students at Saint Augustine University of Tanzania, Mwanza, Tanzania: A Cross-Sectional Study

Frank Deus Samson; Paskas Wagana; Johnson Mavole International journal of social sciences and humanities review, 2026

چکیده

Background: Awareness of youth-friendly sexual and reproductive health services (YFSRHS) is an important starting point for enabling young people to identify and seek appropriate sexual and reproductive health information and care. However, awareness of these services may vary across settings, including higher education institutions. Objective: To determine the level of awareness of YFSRHS among undergraduate students at Saint Augustine University of Tanzania (SAUT), Malimbe Campus. Methods: A quantitative descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted among undergraduate students at SAUT Malimbe Campus. Data were collected using a structured, self-administered questionnaire. Of 109 questionnaires distributed, 108 completed questionnaires were included in the analysis. Descriptive statistics were used to summarize students’ awareness and reported sources of information. Results: Of the 108 respondents, 96 (88.9%) reported having heard of YFSRHS, while 12 (11.1%) had not. Social media was the most frequently reported source of information (44.0%), followed by friends or peers (41.0%) and health facilities (36.0%). University programmes and posters or advertisements were reported less frequently. Conclusion: Most respondents had heard of YFSRHS, with social media and peer networks serving as prominent information channels. Strengthening accurate information through these channels, alongside university-based communication, may help address the awareness gap among students who remain unreached.

دسترسی آزاد

Relevansi Nilai-Nilai Peradaban Islam dalam Pengembangan Pendidikan Modern di Era Digital

Arifah Khoirunnisaa; Lisan Nulhasanah Tadabbur Jurnal Peradaban Islam, 2026, Vol. 8, Issue 2 https://doi.org/10.22373/tadabbur.v8i2.1090

چکیده

Islamic civilization is one of the major civilizations that has significantly contributed to the development of science and education worldwide. During its golden age, it established educational institutions, fostered scholarly traditions, and produced influential scholars whose ideas continue to shape modern knowledge in the digital era. This article examines the relevance of Islamic civilizational values to the development of modern education through qualitative library research using thematic content analysis. The findings show that Islamic education was distinguished by four interrelated values, namely a strong culture of literacy, the integration of religious and general knowledge, an emphasis on moral formation (akhlak), and openness to knowledge from other civilizations, which together enabled scholars to advance science while upholding ethical and social responsibility. These values are highly relevant to addressing contemporary educational challenges, including declining critical literacy, uncritical dependence on digital technology and artificial intelligence, and the ongoing crisis of learners’ character. These values can inform the development of a modern educational system that integrates critical thinking, digital literacy, character education, and lifelong learning while maintaining moral and social responsibility.

متن کامل دسترسی آزاد

Emotional Contagion: How Stress in One Person Affects the Mood and Behaviour of Others

Nisha Rawat International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR), 2026, Vol. 15, Issue 10, pp. 2023-2027 https://doi.org/10.21275/sr261028185939

چکیده

Emotional contagion refers to the process through which people's emotions may be influenced by the emotional states and expressions of others. This study examined self-reported responses to stress in other people and explored their association with perceived stress. A quantitative, cross-sectional online questionnaire was completed between October 25 and 27, 2026. Of 33 submissions, 32 participants consented and were included in the emotional-response analysis; 31 had sufficient responses for the preliminary perceived-stress analysis. The questionnaire included 15 researcher-developed statements about responses to others' stress and 10 perceived-stress questions resembling the Perceived Stress Scale?10 (PSS-10). Descriptive results showed that 90.6% of participants agreed or strongly agreed that they could sense stress in people around them, while 75.0% reported that stress in family, workplace, or educational settings affected their emotional well-being. An exploratory Spearman correlation indicated a positive association between the emotional-response composite and perceived-stress scores (rs = .526, p = .002, n = 31). This association must be interpreted cautiously because the emotional-response questionnaire was not validated and the exact perceived-stress instrument requires confirmation. Findings provide preliminary descriptive insight but do not establish causation.

متن کامل دسترسی آزاد

Leadership Qualities and Practices for Effective Leadership: Evidence from Africa Renewal University, Uganda

Richard Drabe Aguta Journal of Economics Finance and Management Studies, 2026, Vol. 09, Issue 10, pp. 5738-5746 https://doi.org/10.47191/jefms/v9-i10-48

چکیده

Effective leadership is important to the functioning and development of private higher education institutions. This study analyzed leadership experiences and perceptions at Africa Renewal University (AfRU), focusing on the qualities and practices perceived to contribute to effective leadership. A mixed-method case study design was used, combining structured questionnaires and semi-structured interviews with students, teaching staff, non-teaching staff, management and senior leaders. The study obtained responses from 133 participants out of a target population of 200, representing a 66.5% response rate. Transformational leadership was the most frequently identified leadership style across all respondent groups, reported by 86.96% of students, 77.5% of teaching staff, 66.67% of non-teaching staff, and 70% of management and senior leaders. Among the leadership qualities examined, integrity and ethics received the highest number of responses, followed by effective communication, problem-solving and decision-making. Empathy and emotional intelligence and visionary thinking were also identified, although their emphasis varied across respondent groups. The findings indicate that perceived leadership effectiveness at AfRU was associated with a combination of ethical conduct, effective communication and practical leadership capabilities within a predominantly transformational leadership context. The study highlights the importance of developing leaders who can combine ethical character with effective communication, decision-making and problem-solving in private higher education.

متن کامل دسترسی آزاد

Estrategia de intervención psicológica motivacional para la mejora del rendimiento físico en las futbolistas femeninas de la sub15

Marla Gabriela Pulley-García; Carlos Hugo Macías Rendón RICEAFS Revista de Investigación en Ciencias de la Educación Actividad Física y Salud, 2026, Issue Edición Especial I, pp. e87 https://doi.org/10.64905/riceafs.eei.e87

چکیده

Introduction: Psychological factors can be important for the physical performance of developing female football players, but research is needed to assess their impact. Objective: To determine the effectiveness of a motivational psychological intervention strategy to improve physical performance in female U-15 football players from a football school in Zone 8 of Guayaquil, Ecuador. Method: Pre-experimental design with a single group and pretest-posttest measurements. Thirty football players participated. For the evaluation of the motivational climate, the PMCSQ-2 was used, while the YYIR1 and the Cooper Test were the instruments employed to assess physical performance. The intervention consisted of 12 sessions of 45 minutes over six weeks. The Shapiro-Wilk test was applied and then the Student's t-test for dependent samples. Results: The overall PMCSQ-2 score did not show statistically significant changes (t(29) = −1.37; p = 0.182; d = −0.250). On the contrary, statistically significant differences with large effect sizes were found for both the YYIR1 (t(29) = −16.08; p < 0.001; d = −2.936) and the Cooper Test (t(29) = −19.54; p < 0.001; d = −3.567). Discussion: Improvements are evident in the evaluated physical indicators, without significant changes in the overall motivational score. This divergence indicates that the physical response and the perception of the motivational climate do not always develop at the same pace. Conclusions: The intervention was associated with significant improvements in physical performance, which supports its application in youth women's football.

سایت ناشر ↗ دسترسی آزاد