Quality of media reporting of suicidal behaviour in India
کیفیت گزارشدهی رسانهای رفتارهای خودکشی در هند
The National Medical Journal of India
2026 Vol. 0, pp. 1-4
https://doi.org/10.25259/nmji_934_2024
چکیده
Background: India has a suicide rate of 18–21 fatalities per 100,000 people (compared to a global rate of 11 per 100,000), constituting around 28% of all suicides worldwide. Conscientious media coverage of suicide is one of the pillars of the World Health Organization's (WHO) life framework for suicide prevention. Media reporting of suicide events has thus far gone without sufficient scrutiny in India. Methods: A scholarly content analysis study was carried out on news articles reporting on suicide attempts and deaths in 6 daily newspapers in India between 1st January 2023, and 31st January 2023. The quality of suicide reporting against the WHO guidelines and the Press Council of India (PCI) 2022 recommendation was assessed. Descriptive statistics were used. Results: A total of 117 articles were analysed. The average number of suicide articles per newspaper per week was 3.9 (range 0.4–13.2). The names, occupation, and method of suicide were mentioned in 93 (79.5%), 58 (49.6%), and 97 (82.9%) of articles, respectively. 58.1% offered a single cause for the suicide event, whereas negative life events were mentioned for 63.2% of the news. All news articles included at least one harmful information according to the WHO media reporting guidelines. 84 (71.8%) news articles violated the recommendation provided in the guideline by not including any helpful information. The reporting of suicide violated the PCI 2022 guidelines in every domain. Conclusion: Media coverage of suicidal behaviour is often suboptimal and fails to meet the standards set by the WHO suicide reporting guidelines and PCI edition 2022 guidelines.
چکیده به فارسی
زمینه: نرخ خودکشی در هند ۱۸ تا ۲۱ مورد فوت به ازای هر ۱۰۰٬۰۰۰ نفر است (در مقایسه با نرخ جهانی ۱۱ مورد به ازای هر ۱۰۰٬۰۰۰ نفر) که حدود ۲۸٪ از کل خودکشیهای جهان را تشکیل میدهد. پوشش مسئولانه رسانهای خودکشی یکی از ارکان چارچوب زندگی سازمان جهانی بهداشت (WHO) برای پیشگیری از خودکشی است. گزارشدهی رسانهای رویدادهای خودکشی تاکنون در هند به اندازه کافی مورد بررسی قرار نگرفته است. روشها: یک مطالعه تحلیل محتوای علمی بر روی مقالات خبری که به گزارش تلاشها و مرگهای ناشی از خودکشی در ۶ روزنامه روزانه هند بین ۱ ژانویه ۲۰۲۳ تا ۳۱ ژانویه ۲۰۲۳ میپرداختند، انجام شد. کیفیت گزارشدهی خودکشی بر اساس دستورالعملهای WHO و توصیه شورای مطبوعات هند (PCI) در سال ۲۰۲۲ ارزیابی شد. از آمار توصیفی استفاده شد. نتایج: در مجموع ۱۱۷ مقاله مورد تحلیل قرار گرفت. میانگین تعداد مقالات مربوط به خودکشی در هر روزنامه در هر هفته ۳٫۹ (دامنه ۰٫۴ تا ۱۳٫۲) بود. نام، شغل و روش خودکشی به ترتیب در ۹۳ (۷۹٫۵٪)، ۵۸ (۴۹٫۶٪) و ۹۷ (۸۲٫۹٪) مقاله ذکر شده بود. ۵۸٫۱٪ از مقالات تنها یک علت برای رویداد خودکشی ارائه داده بودند، در حالی که رویدادهای منفی زندگی در ۶۳٫۲٪ اخبار ذکر شده بود. همه مقالات خبری حداقل یک مورد اطلاعات مضر بر اساس دستورالعملهای گزارشدهی رسانهای WHO داشتند. ۸۴ (۷۱٫۸٪) مقاله خبری با عدم ارائه هرگونه اطلاعات مفید، توصیه ارائهشده در دستورالعمل را نقض کرده بودند. گزارشدهی خودکشی در همه حوزهها با دستورالعملهای PCI 2022 مغایرت داشت. نتیجهگیری: پوشش رسانهای رفتارهای خودکشی اغلب بهینه نیست و استانداردهای تعیینشده توسط دستورالعملهای گزارشدهی خودکشی WHO و نسخه ۲۰۲۲ دستورالعملهای PCI را رعایت نمیکند.
ترجمهی خودکار برای آشنایی سریع؛ برای نقل و ارجاع، متن اصلی ملاک است.
موضوعها و کلیدواژهها
ارجاع
(Debnath & SURI, 2026)
گفتوگو
قوانین پرسش و گفتگو
- با احترام و بدون توهین، تحقیر، برچسبزنی یا حملهی شخصی با دیگران گفتگو کنید.
- از نوشتن هرگونه اطلاعات هویتی یا قابلشناسایی مراجعان، بیماران یا اشخاص ثالث، از جمله نام، شمارهی تماس، تصویر، نشانی، محل کار یا جزئیات منحصربهفرد پرونده خودداری کنید.
- اگر دربارهی یک تجربهی بالینی سؤال میکنید، اطلاعات را تا حد ممکن بینام و کلی بیان کنید تا امکان شناسایی فرد وجود نداشته باشد.
- این بخش برای یادگیری و گفتوگوی علمی است و جایگزین ارزیابی، تشخیص، مشاوره یا رواندرمانی شخصی نیست.
- در شرایط بحران یا خطر آسیب به خود یا دیگران، به این بخش اتکا نکنید و برای دریافت کمک فوری با اورژانس اجتماعی ۱۲۳ یا صدای مشاور بهزیستی ۱۴۸۰ تماس بگیرید.
- انتشار تبلیغات، معرفی خدمات شخصی، شمارهی تلفن، شناسهی شبکههای اجتماعی، پیوند تبلیغاتی یا درخواست جذب مراجع در این بخش مجاز نیست.
- در بیان ادعاهای علمی، بهویژه دربارهی اثربخشی درمانها، تشخیص یا یافتههای پژوهشی، تا حد امکان نام منبع معتبر، مقاله یا راهنمای علمی را ذکر کنید.
- از ارائهی تشخیص قطعی، تجویز درمان یا دارو و توصیههای بالینی شخصی به سایر کاربران خودداری کنید.
- پاسخهایی که کارشناسان فکر بنیان میدهند با برچسب «پاسخ فکر بنیان» یا «کارشناس فکر بنیان» نمایش داده میشوند و سایر نوشتهها بیانگر نظر کاربران هستند.
- گزارش نوشتهی نامناسب: اگر نوشتهای حاوی نقض محرمانگی، محتوای آسیبزا، توهین، تبلیغ یا تخلف از این قوانین است، گزینهی «گزارش» را انتخاب کنید تا تیم سایت بررسی کند.
برای پرسیدن و پاسخ دادن باید مشترک باشید. ورود
هنوز پرسشی منتشر نشده است.
مقالههای مرتبط
A Comparison of Suicidal Behaviors Among Middle and High School Students in Two Municipalities in Hidalgo, Mexico
چکیده
Introduction: Suicidal behaviors among adolescents are increasing globally, yet the differences between educational levels remain unclear, which hinders the design of specific prevention strategies. Objective: To compare suicidal behaviors (ideation, risk factors, and depression) between middle school and high school students in Pachuca and San Agustín Tlaxiaca, Hidalgo, Mexico. Methodology: A quantitative, cross-sectional, comparative, non-experimental study was conducted with 38 students (20 middle school students, 18 high school students) aged 14 to 18 years. Three instruments were applied: a test to assess the risk level of suicidal ideation and behavior, a risk factor guide, and the PHQ-9 depression questionnaire. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and the Mann-Whitney U test. Results: Middle school students had a higher proportion of high risk for suicidal behaviors (30.00%) compared to high school students (5.56%). A high level of depression was found only in high school seniors (11.11%). Both groups showed similar proportions of high risk based on risk factors (25.00% in middle school and 22.22% in high school). A significant positive correlation (ρ = 0.52) was found between suicidal thoughts and risk factors (p < 0.05). The Mann-Whitney U test revealed no significant differences between groups. (U = 145.5; p = 0.312). Conclusions: Although no statistically significant differences were found between educational levels and the groups were confounded by institution, municipality, and age, a trend toward a higher proportion of high risk for suicidal behaviors was observed in middle school students and of high depression in high school students. These findings should be interpreted with caution and support the need for prevention programs tailored to each educational level, to be confirmed in studies with greater statistical power and adjustment for confounders.
Symptoms of borderline personality disorder in young men from the general population: prevalence, age-related changes, and longitudinal associations with risk-taking behaviors
چکیده
Abstract Background Borderline personality disorder (BPD) is a severe mental illness associated with emotional and functional impairment, elevated suicide risk, and high individual and societal costs. BPD is under-researched in the general population, especially among males, and from a developmental perspective. We examined the prevalence and development of BPD symptoms in young men and explored the longitudinal associations with risk-taking behaviors. Methods Data came from the prospective-longitudinal Cohort Study on Substance Use Risk Factors (C-SURF), a population sample of young men. Participants were screened for BPD risk using the McLean Screening Instrument (MSI-BPD) at mean age 25 (2016–2018; n = 5,516) and again at mean age 28 (2019–2020; n = 5,367). Risk-taking behaviors (e.g., interpersonal violence, gambling, substance use) were self-reported at both time points. Multilevel regression models examined within-person changes in BPD symptoms, including self-harm, and risk-taking behaviors over time. Results 7.4% of participants had a high risk of BPD, defined by endorsing 7 + MSI-BPD items at least once. Among those with 7 + items endorsed at the first assessment, 29.5% still endorsed 7 + items three years later. Despite a general within-person decline in BPD symptoms with age, participants at initially high risk for BPD continued to exhibit elevated levels of risk-taking behaviors after three years. Conclusion BPD symptomatology affects a substantial proportion of young men. Despite its modest stability over time, it is associated with persistent engagement in various risk-taking behaviors. Interventions targeting BPD symptoms in male populations may offer a promising avenue towards mitigating substantial psychosocial burden associated with these behaviors.
Prevalence, knowledge and predictors of Text Neck Syndrome among undergraduate students in East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya, India: a cross-sectional study
چکیده
Background: Young adults' extensive use of smartphones has resulted in several health concerns and one of which is Text Neck Syndrome. Prolonged neck flexion during smartphone use can lead to neck pain, disability and functional limitations. The study focused on determining the prevalence and knowledge regarding Text Neck Syndrome and identify predicting factors associated with the condition. Methods: A cross-sectional study was carried out among 240 undergraduate students selected using convenience method of sampling from four colleges in East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya. A standardized questionnaire with questions on demographics, participant behaviour and understanding of text neck syndrome was used to gather data. Two standardized tools neck disability index and the smartphone addiction scale-short version were used with prior permission to assess neck disability and smartphone addiction.8,9 Results: The results demonstrated that, prevalence of Text Neck Syndrome among the participants discovered to be 35.8% (95% CI:29.8%–42.3%) and 41.0% participants had smartphone addiction. Majority (71.7%) participants had adequate knowledge regarding Text Neck Syndrome and smartphone addiction was identified as a significant independent predictor of Text Neck Syndrome, with 2.2 times higher odds of developing the condition. Additionally, there was a significant positive correlation found between smartphone addiction and neck disability. Conclusions: Text Neck Syndrome is a prevalent health issue among undergraduate students in Meghalaya, affecting more than one-third of the study population. Although most of the participants had adequate knowledge regarding text neck syndrome, the occurrence of the syndrome suggests the need of targeted educational, ergonomic and behavioural interventions among young adults.
Psychometric properties of the Literacy of Suicide Scale (LOSS-SF) and the Stigma of Suicide Scale (SOSS-SF) in a Hungarian sample
چکیده
Although knowledge and stigma about suicide are important factors in suicide prevention, there are no validated instruments available in Hungary. Our goal was to validate the Literacy of Suicide Scale—Short Form (LOSS-SF) and the Stigma of Suicide Scale—Short Form (SOSS-SF) in Hungarian. An anonymous online survey was administered to a self-selected online convenience sample of 954 participants of 38.0 years (SD: 14.8) of age. Our study used a descriptive, correlational, cross-sectional design. Confirmatory factor analysis results indicate a good model fit for a three-factor structure of the SOSS-SF scale. Invariance testing revealed that the scale is valid across gender, age and former suicide ideation. LOSS-SF had an acceptable unidimensional model fit as a two-parameter logistic (2PL) IRT (Item Response Theory) based survey, and results showed good infit–outfit with appropriate item discrimination and difficulty measures. The results show that the two instruments show sound psychometric properties and construct validity within this sample. While the Hungarian versions of the SOSS-SF and the LOSS-SF provide useful tools for assessing suicide stigma and suicide literacy in research settings, further validation on nationally representative samples may be required in case population-level norms are needed to inform national policy-makers.