Assessment in Arabic language learning as a foreign language (Arabic as a Foreign Language) is currently undergoing a significant paradigm shift. This transformation is influenced by the development of digital technology, the utilization of Artificial Intelligence (AI), and the implementation of the Merdeka Curriculum in Indonesia, which emphasizes flexibility, differentiation, and learning personalization. This article presents a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) aimed at identifying, examining, and synthesizing developments, innovations, methodological approaches, and various challenges in the assessment of the four Arabic language skills, namely listening, speaking, reading, and writing, during the period from 2020 to early 2026. The review employed the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) protocol to identify and analyze relevant literature. The findings indicate a shift from conventional evaluation systems based on discrete tests toward the implementation of Technology-Enhanced Assessment (TEA) and more authentic forms of assessment. The literature synthesis reveals several key findings. First, diagnostic assessment, encompassing both cognitive and non-cognitive aspects, plays an important role in designing differentiated learning within the framework of the Merdeka Curriculum. Second, the development of assessment instruments for Arabic language maharah is increasingly oriented toward measuring higher-order thinking skills (Higher Order Thinking Skills/HOTS). Third, the utilization of Generative AI, including ChatGPT, as well as various gamification-based learning platforms, has introduced new approaches to providing faster, more adaptive, and interactive feedback. Based on the synthesis, the effectiveness of modern assessment is not determined solely by the sophistication of the technology employed, but also by the alignment between technology and pedagogical objectives, the transparency of assessment procedures, and its ability to comprehensively represent learners' communicative competence while maintaining the principles of academic integrity.
The emergence of generative artificial intelligence (Generative AI), such as ChatGPT, has brought significant changes to higher education, including Arabic language learning for non-native speakers (Arabic as a Foreign Language). Writing skills (Maharah al-Kitabah) are considered a relatively complex productive skill. Learners are required not only to master word formation (Sarf) and Arabic grammar (Nahwu), but also to organize ideas coherently and logically. This article employs a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) approach based on the PRISMA 2020 standards to map the use of ChatGPT in Arabic writing, examine the reliability of AI in Arabic grammar, and identify research gaps that remain underexplored. The review findings indicate that ChatGPT can serve as a useful writing partner (human-AI co-writer), particularly for generating ideas, enriching vocabulary, and correcting basic grammatical errors. However, AI still frequently produces errors or “hallucinations” when dealing with morphologically complex words, variations in Arabic dialects, and unvocalized texts. As a result, AI-generated writing may appear linguistically polished on the surface while containing grammatical inaccuracies. Furthermore, excessive reliance on AI may pose risks to academic integrity, while AI detection tools themselves often produce inaccurate results when identifying Arabic-language texts (false positives). This review also finds that existing research remains overly focused on English, tends to examine only the final writing outcomes without investigating students’ cognitive processes, and has paid limited attention to AI models specifically developed for the Arab region, such as ALLaM and Jais. Therefore, the approach to AI-assisted learning needs to shift from merely using AI toward purposeful and reflective utilization through frameworks such as the Spiral Learning Model and Genre-Based Pedagogy, so that AI functions as a scaffold without diminishing students’ autonomy and critical thinking.
Tamil translations may facilitate Arabic language acquisition among Tamil-speaking learners in Sri Lanka; however, their effectiveness as a learning resource requires further examination. This research aims to analyse the contribution of Tamil translations to Arabic language learning, assess their role in improving vocabulary comprehension, and identify the strategies and challenges associated with their use. A descriptive-analytical approach was adopted, with a questionnaire comprising 20 questions across nine thematic areas administered to students learning Arabic at government universities in Sri Lanka. The findings indicate that translated books serve as valuable supplementary resources, particularly in clarifying unfamiliar vocabulary and facilitating the comprehension of Arabic texts. Learners demonstrate considerable confidence in translated materials and compare them with original Arabic texts only to a limited extent. Furthermore, the findings report a 97% correspondence rate between translated lexical equivalents and source-language words. Translators reportedly employ a combination of literal, interpretive, abridged, and adaptive translation strategies to address linguistic and semantic challenges. These findings highlight the pedagogical potential of Tamil translations in supporting Arabic language acquisition. The research recommends improving translation quality, developing bilingual educational resources, and integrating translated materials with original Arabic texts to enhance learners’ linguistic competence and promote effective Arabic language learning in Sri Lanka.
The landscape of foreign language education, particularly Arabic language instruction, is currently undergoing a fundamental transformation driven by the emergence of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) and Large Language Models (LLMs). This Systematic Literature Review evaluates recent developments in the integration of GenAI into the Arabic language learning ecosystem, encompassing trends in the evolution of language models, pedagogical effectiveness, the utilization of automated assessment systems, as well as the linguistic and cultural challenges involved. Through a thematic synthesis of empirical and theoretical literature published between 2019 and 2026, this review confirms that GenAI significantly enhances learner engagement, instructional personalization, and language skill acquisition, particularly in vocabulary mastery and reading comprehension. These improvements are driven by the adoption of general-purpose models such as ChatGPT, as well as leading Arabic-centric models such as JAIS and ALLaM. Nevertheless, this innovative integration encounters the inherent structural complexity of the Arabic language. Generative models frequently experience technical limitations in handling syntactic rules (nahwu), morphology (shorof), diacritic disambiguation, and regional dialect variations, as evidenced by performance gaps in linguistic benchmarks such as AraLingBench and AlGhafa. Furthermore, this review discusses rapid advances in trait-based Automated Essay Scoring (AES) supported by precise prompt engineering. Based on these findings, the study concludes that although GenAI has significant potential to bring positive disruption, its successful implementation depends heavily on pedagogical readiness, digital literacy, the application of Human-in-the-Loop (HITL) collaboration, and the development of ethical frameworks aligned with the epistemology of Islamic higher education.
Vocabulary (mufrodat) mastery underpins speaking skills (maharah kalam), yet elementary Islamic school students may struggle to use vocabulary in speech and retain memorized words after instruction. This study aimed to analyze the effectiveness of El-Syarif-based vocabulary instruction in improving speaking skills and memorization retention among students at MI Najahiyah Palembang. A quantitative approach was employed using a quasi-experimental one-group pretest-posttest design. The sample comprised 35 fifth-grade students selected through total sampling. Data were collected through oral speaking tests, an immediate memorization test, and a delayed memorization test. The data were analyzed using descriptive statistics, a paired-samples t-test, the Wilcoxon Signed Rank test, and N-Gain. The results showed that the mean speaking score increased from 57.37 to 81.63, with an N-Gain of 0.58, categorized as moderate, and a statistically significant difference (p < 0.001). The mean memorization score decreased from 83.37 to 79.31, while retention reached 95.1%. These findings indicate that El-Syarif-based instruction can improve students’ speaking skills and help maintain most memorized vocabulary. However, the decline in delayed-test scores indicates that some vocabulary was still forgotten over time. ABSTRAK Penguasaan mufrodat menjadi dasar keterampilan berbicara (maharah kalam), tetapi siswa madrasah ibtidaiyah masih menghadapi kesulitan menggunakan kosakata dalam ujaran dan mempertahankan hafalan setelah pembelajaran. Penelitian ini bertujuan menganalisis efektivitas pembelajaran mufrodat berbasis metode El-Syarif dalam meningkatkan maharah kalam dan retensi hafalan siswa di MI Najahiyah Palembang. Penelitian menggunakan pendekatan kuantitatif dengan metode eksperimen semu (quasi-experimental) berdesain one-group pretest-posttest. Sampel terdiri atas 35 siswa kelas V yang dipilih melalui teknik total sampling. Data dikumpulkan melalui tes lisan, tes hafalan segera, dan tes hafalan tunda, kemudian dianalisis menggunakan statistik deskriptif, uji paired-samples t-test, uji Wilcoxon Signed Rank, dan N-Gain. Hasil menunjukkan bahwa rata-rata maharah kalam meningkat dari 57,37 menjadi 81,63, dengan N-Gain 0,58 dalam kategori sedang dan perbedaan signifikan (p < 0,001). Rata-rata hafalan menurun dari 83,37 menjadi 79,31, tetapi retensi mencapai 95,1%. Disimpulkan bahwa metode El-Syarif berpotensi meningkatkan keterampilan berbicara sekaligus mempertahankan sebagian besar hafalan siswa, meskipun penurunan hafalan tetap terjadi.
The ability to comprehend classical Islamic texts (kitab turats) is one of the essential competencies in Arabic language learning within Islamic boarding schools. However, many students encounter difficulties in identifying grammatical functions, analyzing Arabic syntactic and morphological structures, and understanding unvocalized Arabic texts. This study aimed to develop the Al-Barqy instructional material based on Visual-Spatial Intelligence, evaluate its validity, and examine its effectiveness in improving students' comprehension of kitab turats in the sorogan learning program at Markaz Al-'Arabiyah Pare Kediri. This research employed the Research and Development (R&D) approach consisting of needs analysis, product design, development, expert validation, revision, field testing, and evaluation. Data were collected through observations, interviews, documentation, validation questionnaires, pretests, and posttests. The data were analyzed using descriptive and inferential statistics. The findings revealed that the developed instructional material successfully integrated colors, grammatical symbols, concept maps, and visual representations as applications of Visual-Spatial Intelligence. Expert validation indicated a feasibility score of 97%, categorized as highly valid. The effectiveness test using a paired-samples t-test yielded a t-value of 20.13 with df = 14 and p < 0.001, indicating a significant difference between the pretest and posttest scores.Therefore, the Al-Barqy instructional material is considered valid, effective, and applicable as an innovative instructional resource for enhancing students' comprehension of kitab turats through the sorogan learning model.
توانایی درک متون کلاسیک اسلامی (کتاب تراث) یکی از شایستگیهای اساسی در یادگیری زبان عربی در مدارس علوم دینی اسلامی بهشمار میرود. با این حال، بسیاری از دانشآموزان در شناسایی نقشهای دستوری، تحلیل ساختارهای نحوی و صرفی زبان عربی، و فهم متون عربی بدون اعرابگذاری با دشواری مواجه هستند. هدف این پژوهش، تدوین محتوای آموزشی البرقی مبتنی بر هوش دیداری-فضایی، ارزیابی روایی آن و بررسی اثربخشی آن در بهبود درک دانشآموزان از کتاب تراث در برنامه آموزشی سورگان در مرکز العربیه پاره کدیری بود. این پژوهش با رویکرد تحقیق و توسعه (R&D) شامل تحلیل نیازها، طراحی محصول، توسعه، اعتبارسنجی توسط خبرگان، بازنگری، آزمون میدانی و ارزیابی انجام شد. دادهها از طریق مشاهده، مصاحبه، اسناد، پرسشنامههای اعتبارسنجی، پیشآزمون و پسآزمون گردآوری شدند. تحلیل دادهها با استفاده از آمار توصیفی و استنباطی صورت گرفت. یافتهها نشان داد که محتوای آموزشی تدوینشده با موفقیت رنگها، نمادهای دستوری، نقشههای مفهومی و بازنماییهای دیداری را بهعنوان کاربردهای هوش دیداری-فضایی ادغام کرده است. اعتبارسنجی خبرگان، امتیاز قابلیت استفاده ۹۷٪ را نشان داد که در دسته بسیار معتبر قرار میگیرد. آزمون اثربخشی با استفاده از آزمون t زوجی مقدار t برابر با 20.13 با درجه آزادی 14 و p < 0.001 را نشان داد که بیانگر تفاوت معنادار بین نمرات پیشآزمون و پسآزمون است. بنابراین، محتوای آموزشی البرقی معتبر، اثربخش و قابل استفاده بهعنوان منبع آموزشی نوآورانه برای ارتقای درک دانشآموزان از کتاب تراث از طریق مدل یادگیری سورگان تلقی میشود.
This study aims to develop interactive learning media based on Articulate Storyline 3 to improve reading skills (maharah al-qirā’ah) in seventh-grade students at MTs Negeri 1 Gorontalo City. The method used was Research and Development (R&D) with the ADDIE model (Analysis, Design, Development, Implementation, and Evaluation). The subjects were 35 students in grade VII.12. Data were obtained through validation by media experts, material experts, and linguists, as well as teacher and student questionnaire responses. The validation results showed the media was categorized as very suitable, with 100% of media experts, 82.5% of material experts, and 80% of linguists. Student response to the media's use reached 80.36% and teacher response 83.33%, categorized as very good. Thus, the learning media based on Articulate Storyline 3 is declared valid, practical, and suitable for use in Arabic language learning, specifically Maharah al-Qirā’ah.
این پژوهش با هدف توسعه رسانه یادگیری تعاملی مبتنی بر Articulate Storyline 3 به منظور ارتقاء مهارت خواندن (مهارت القِراءه) در دانشآموزان پایه هفتم مدرسه MTs Negeri 1 شهر گورونتالو انجام شده است. روش مورد استفاده، پژوهش و توسعه (R&D) با مدل ADDIE (تحلیل، طراحی، توسعه، اجرا و ارزیابی) بود. شرکتکنندگان شامل ۳۵ دانشآموز پایه هفتم کلاس VII.12 بودند. دادهها از طریق اعتبارسنجی توسط خبرگان رسانه، خبرگان محتوا و زبانشناسان، همچنین پرسشنامههای معلمان و دانشآموزان جمعآوری شد. نتایج اعتبارسنجی نشان داد که رسانه در دسته «بسیار مناسب» قرار دارد؛ بهطوریکه ۱۰۰٪ از خبرگان رسانه، ۸۲.۵٪ از خبرگان محتوا و ۸۰٪ از زبانشناسان این رسانه را تأیید کردند. پاسخ دانشآموزان به استفاده از این رسانه به ۸۰.۳۶٪ و پاسخ معلمان به ۸۳.۳۳٪ رسید که هر دو در دسته «بسیار خوب» قرار گرفتند. بنابراین، رسانه یادگیری مبتنی بر Articulate Storyline 3 معتبر، کاربردی و مناسب برای استفاده در آموزش زبان عربی، بهویژه مهارت القِراءه، اعلام میشود.
Arabic language communication skills have become an important competence for madrasah students, not only as an academic ability but also as a means of understanding Islamic knowledge and developing cultural identity. However, Arabic language learning at the elementary level still faces challenges in transforming vocabulary and grammatical knowledge into real communication practices. This study aims to analyze the implementation of an Arabic Language Program in improving students’ communicative competence at MIN Wonosobo. This research employed a qualitative approach with a case study design. Data were collected through in-depth interviews, observations, and document analysis involving 13 participants consisting of the head of the madrasah, curriculum coordinator, Arabic language teacher, program mentors, and students. The data were analyzed using thematic analysis. The findings revealed four main themes: Arabic as a madrasah identity, the transition from vocabulary mastery to communication practice, students’ emotional experiences in speaking Arabic, and challenges in developing a language environment. The study demonstrates that communicative competence is shaped through the interaction between school programs, pedagogical practices, and students’ social experiences. These findings contribute to the development of more contextual and communicative Arabic language programs in Islamic elementary education.
مهارتهای ارتباطی زبان عربی به عنوان یکی از شایستگیهای مهم برای دانشآموزان مدارس، نه تنها به عنوان یک توانایی علمی بلکه به عنوان ابزاری برای فهم دانش اسلامی و توسعه هویت فرهنگی اهمیت یافته است. با این حال، آموزش زبان عربی در سطح ابتدایی همچنان با چالشهایی در تبدیل دانش واژگان و دستور زبان به کاربرد واقعی در ارتباطات مواجه است. هدف این پژوهش، تحلیل اجرای برنامه زبان عربی در بهبود شایستگی ارتباطی دانشآموزان در MIN Wonosobo است. این پژوهش با رویکرد کیفی و با طرح مطالعه موردی انجام شده است. دادهها از طریق مصاحبههای عمیق، مشاهده و تحلیل اسناد با مشارکت ۱۳ نفر شامل رئیس مدرسه، هماهنگکننده برنامه درسی، معلم زبان عربی، مربیان برنامه و دانشآموزان گردآوری شد. دادهها با استفاده از تحلیل تماتیک مورد بررسی قرار گرفت. یافتهها چهار مضمون اصلی را نشان داد: زبان عربی به عنوان هویت مدرسه، گذار از تسلط واژگانی به تمرین ارتباطی، تجارب هیجانی دانشآموزان در صحبت کردن به زبان عربی و چالشهای توسعه محیط زبانی. این مطالعه نشان میدهد که شایستگی ارتباطی از طریق تعامل میان برنامههای مدرسه، شیوههای آموزشی و تجارب اجتماعی دانشآموزان شکل میگیرد. این یافتهها به توسعه برنامههای زبان عربی زمینهمندتر و ارتباطیتر در آموزش ابتدایی اسلامی کمک میکند.
Background-Tenth-grade students at Riyadhussholihiin Senior High School reported difficulties understanding existing Arabic textbooks due to limited explanations, exercises, multimedia support, and independent learning opportunities. A needs analysis involving 29 students showed that 80% strongly needed more accessible and engaging digital materials. Objectives-This study aimed to (1) develop Google Sites-based interactive Arabic teaching materials; (2) determine their feasibility; and (3) examine students’ reading, listening, writing, and speaking outcomes. Methods-This Research and Development study employed th ADDIE model. Data were collected through observation, interviews, needs-analysis questionnaires, expert-validation sheets, and pretest-posttest assessments. Results-The resulting Google Sites materials integrated texts, pronunciation audio, instructional videos, images, interactive exercises, and quizzes. The material-validation score was 87.98% (44/50), whereas the media-validation score was 82.86% (29/35). Students provided positive responses to the materials, with an overall response score of 87.98%. The reported mean total score increased from 59.30 before implementation to 73.99 after implementation, an increase of 24.77%; listening showed the largest percentage increase (29.45%). Conclusions-The materials were feasible for use and were associated with improved Arabic language learning-outcome scores in the participating class. The conclusion is limited to the study cohort and should not be interpreted as a separate claim about student motivation.
زمینه و هدف: دانشآموزان پایه دهم دبیرستان Riyadhussholihiin گزارش کردند که به دلیل محدودیت در توضیحات، تمرینها، پشتیبانی چندرسانهای و فرصتهای یادگیری مستقل، درک کتابهای درسی عربی موجود برای آنها دشوار است. تحلیل نیازسنجی با مشارکت ۲۹ دانشآموز نشان داد که ۸۰٪ آنها به شدت به مواد دیجیتال قابل دسترستر و جذابتر نیاز دارند. اهداف: این پژوهش با هدف (۱) تدوین مواد آموزشی تعاملی زبان عربی مبتنی بر Google Sites؛ (۲) تعیین میزان قابلیت استفاده آنها؛ و (۳) بررسی نتایج یادگیری دانشآموزان در مهارتهای خواندن، شنیدن، نوشتن و صحبت کردن انجام شد. روشها: این مطالعه از نوع پژوهش و توسعه و مبتنی بر مدل ADDIE بود. دادهها از طریق مشاهده، مصاحبه، پرسشنامه نیازسنجی، فرمهای اعتبارسنجی خبرگان و آزمونهای پیشآزمون-پسآزمون گردآوری شد. یافتهها: مواد آموزشی تدوینشده در Google Sites شامل متون، فایلهای صوتی تلفظ، ویدئوهای آموزشی، تصاویر، تمرینهای تعاملی و آزمونها بود. امتیاز اعتبارسنجی محتوا ۸۷/۹۸٪ (۴۴ از ۵۰) و امتیاز اعتبارسنجی رسانه ۸۲/۸۶٪ (۲۹ از ۳۵) به دست آمد. دانشآموزان پاسخهای مثبتی به این مواد ارائه دادند و امتیاز کلی پاسخدهی ۸۷/۹۸٪ بود. میانگین نمره کل از ۵۹/۳۰ پیش از اجرا به ۷۳/۹۹ پس از اجرا افزایش یافت که معادل ۲۴/۷۷٪ رشد بود؛ بیشترین افزایش درصدی مربوط به مهارت شنیداری (۲۹/۴۵٪) بود. نتیجهگیری: مواد آموزشی تدوینشده از نظر قابلیت استفاده مناسب بودند و با بهبود نمرات یادگیری زبان عربی در کلاس مورد مطالعه همراه بودند. نتیجهگیری صرفاً به نمونه پژوهش محدود است و نباید به عنوان ادعایی مستقل درباره انگیزش دانشآموزان تفسیر شود.
This study aims to develop an Arabic language learning module based on Higher Order Thinking Skills (HOTS) to improve students' higher-order thinking skills at the Faculty of Teacher Training and Education, University of Muhammadiyah North Sumatra (UMSU). The study used the Research and Development (R&D) method with the ADDIE model which includes the stages of Analysis, Design, Development, Implementation, and Evaluation. At the analysis stage, it was found that Arabic language learning was still dominated by low-order thinking skills (LOTS) and did not provide analytical, evaluative, and creative activities as required by the OBE curriculum. The developed module was validated by material experts and learning design experts with the assessment results being in the very feasible category. A limited trial on 32 students showed a significant increase in HOTS skills, evidenced by the difference in pre-test and post-test scores, as well as an increase in the ability to analyze texts, evaluate arguments, and produce new texts in Arabic. Student responses were also very positive towards the use of the module because it was considered interesting, challenging, and helped understand Arabic texts more deeply. The results of the study indicate that the HOTS-based Arabic language learning module is effective, feasible to use, and has the potential to be widely applied in Arabic language courses at universities..
هدف این پژوهش توسعهٔ یک ماژول آموزش زبان عربی مبتنی بر مهارتهای تفکر سطوح بالاتر (HOTS) به منظور ارتقای مهارتهای تفکر سطح بالای دانشجویان در دانشکدهٔ تربیت معلم و آموزش دانشگاه محمدیه شمال سوماترا (UMSU) است. این پژوهش از روش تحقیق و توسعه (R&D) با مدل ADDIE که شامل مراحل تحلیل، طراحی، توسعه، اجرا و ارزیابی است، استفاده کردهاست. در مرحلهٔ تحلیل مشخص شد که آموزش زبان عربی همچنان تحت سلطهٔ مهارتهای تفکر سطوح پایین (LOTS) قرار دارد و فعالیتهای تحلیلی، ارزیابی و خلاقانه مطابق با الزامات برنامهٔ درسی OBE ارائه نمیشود. ماژول توسعهیافته توسط متخصصان محتوا و طراحی آموزشی اعتبارسنجی شد و نتایج ارزیابی در دستهٔ «بسیار قابل قبول» قرار گرفت. آزمون محدودی بر روی ۳۲ دانشجو نشان داد که مهارتهای HOTS به طور معناداری افزایش یافتهاست، که این امر با تفاوت نمرات پیشآزمون و پسآزمون و همچنین افزایش توانایی تحلیل متون، ارزیابی استدلالها و تولید متون جدید به زبان عربی مشهود است. واکنش دانشجویان نیز نسبت به استفاده از این ماژول بسیار مثبت بود، زیرا آن را جالب، چالشبرانگیز و کمککننده به درک عمیقتر متون عربی دانستند. نتایج پژوهش نشان میدهد که ماژول آموزش زبان عربی مبتنی بر HOTS مؤثر، قابل استفاده و دارای پتانسیل کاربرد گسترده در دروس زبان عربی در دانشگاهها است.
Mufrodat mastery constitutes the primary foundation of Arabic language acquisition. Students at non-formal Quranic schools (TPQ) in rural areas are generally not yet systematically exposed to basic Arabic vocabulary. This Ramadan 1447H KKN-T community service aimed to improve mastery of body-part Arabic mufrodat among 18 TPQ students at Mushalla Khairul Ikhwan, Nagari Sago Salido, Pesisir Selatan, using picture-poster media. A Service Learning approach with a one-group pretest-posttest measurement design was employed in collaboration with local TPQ teachers. Data were analyzed using paired t-test, Hake N-Gain, and Cohen’s d. Mean scores increased from 74.89 to 91.17. The paired t-test yielded t = 15.68 (p < .001), mean N-Gain g̅ = 0.750 (high category), and Cohen’s d = 3.70 (very large effect). Picture-poster media proved effective and applicable for Arabic mufrodat instruction in non-formal educational settings.
تسلط بر مفردات، زیربنای اصلی فراگیری زبان عربی را تشکیل میدهد. دانشآموزان مدارس غیررسمی قرآنی (TPQ) در مناطق روستایی عموماً به طور نظاممند با واژگان پایه زبان عربی آشنا نمیشوند. هدف خدمترسانی اجتماعی KKN-T رمضان ۱۴۴۷ هجری، ارتقای تسلط بر مفردات اعضای بدن به زبان عربی در میان ۱۸ دانشآموز TPQ در مصلی خیرالاخوان، نگاری ساگو سالیدو، پسیسیر سلاتان با استفاده از رسانه پوسترهای تصویری بود. رویکرد یادگیری خدمتمحور با طرح اندازهگیری پیشآزمون-پسآزمون تکگروهی و با همکاری معلمان محلی TPQ به کار گرفته شد. دادهها با استفاده از آزمون t زوجی، Hake N-Gain و d کوهن تحلیل شدند. میانگین نمرات از ۷۴٫۸۹ به ۹۱٫۱۷ افزایش یافت. آزمون t زوجی مقدار t = ۱۵٫۶۸ (p < ۰٫۰۰۱)، میانگین N-Gain g̅ = ۰٫۷۵۰ (طبقه بالا) و d کوهن = ۳٫۷۰ (اثر بسیار بزرگ) را نشان داد. رسانه پوسترهای تصویری برای آموزش مفردات عربی در محیطهای آموزشی غیررسمی مؤثر و قابل اجرا بود.